Italy’s education ministry has banned gender-neutral symbols in schools, citing breaches of grammatical norms.
The Ministry of Education and Merit issued a directive on Friday, halting the use of symbols like the asterisk (*) and schwa (ə).
This decision follows a few complaints about their use in school communications.
Student Stance: Defying Rules with Schwa
A student at Rome’s Plinio Seniore school used the schwa throughout their exam two years ago.
They earned 17/20, despite initial worries about a lower mark for flouting tradition.
The student explained, "The schwa… has now entered my way of thinking, and it would be tricky not to use it to express myself."
Naturally, this bold choice tested the limits of academic language rules. Advocates for inclusivity praised the student’s effort to expand Italian expression.
However, the Ministry of Education and Merit soon responded with a formal ban.
Ministry’s Mandate: Clarity Over Creativity Today
On Friday, Giuseppe Valditara, Minister of Education and Merit, issued a circular banning gender-neutral symbols.
The ministry states that "the use of non-compliant graphic signs… risks undermining the clarity and uniformity of institutional communication."
Ten complaints about schools using these symbols in recent months prompted this action.
Consequently, Giuseppe Valditara moved quickly to reinforce standard Italian grammar.
The ministry acted after receiving reports of occasional use on school websites. Still, such scarce instances hardly warrant a nationwide directive.
Accademia’s Anchor: Tradition Steers the Ban
The Accademia della Crusca, Italy’s oldest linguistic academy, supports the ministry’s position.
It has warned that gender-neutral symbols "obstruct the readability and accessibility of texts" in official documents. This advice lends academic heft to the ban.
Moreover, the Accademia della Crusca notes that the schwa lacks a spoken form in Italian, clouding legal texts.
Critics argue this overlooks chances for language to grow with society. Thus, the academy’s view props up Italy banning gender-neutral language.
Meloni’s Mission: Heritage Moulds Policy
Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s government champions this ban as part of a cultural plan.
Since 2022, Giorgia Meloni has chosen the masculine “il presidente” over “la presidente” for her title.
Her Brothers of Italy party prizes language as a bedrock of national identity.
Additionally, the government has swapped progressive cultural leaders for traditionalists across institutions. This policy fits their goal to guard Italy’s linguistic legacy against emerging trends.
Giorgia Meloni’s administration thus powers Italy banning gender-neutral language.
Public Perspectives: A Country Divided Quietly
Public views on the ban split between traditionalists and inclusivity advocates, though data stays thin.
Sexual minority and women’s rights groups criticise the decision, claiming it sidelines gender-diverse individuals. Supporters cheer it as a bulwark for Italian grammar’s purity.
For example, a university rector once used feminine titles universally, stirring brief outcry. The trial ended, while Giorgia Meloni’s masculine title holds firm, echoing rooted norms.
Without wider surveys—an information gap here—public opinion stays hazy.
Historical Echoes: Language as Cultural Flashpoint
Italy’s language disputes reach back years, tied to grammar’s gendered framework.
In 2023, the University of Trento’s rector applied feminine titles to all in a document. The choice drew flak and soon lapsed, proving aversion to change.
Similarly, Giuseppe Valditara’s ministry rests on the Accademia della Crusca’s earlier rulings against such symbols. These past cases link directly to the current ban, tracing a thread of linguistic orthodoxy.
Yet, younger voices steadily prod this firmness.
Grammar’s Grasp: Rules vs. Inclusion
Italian grammar assigns gender to nouns, rooted in Romance language customs.
Activists adopt the schwa to forge neutral endings, aiming to embrace gender-neutral individuals. The ministry and Accademia della Crusca dismiss this as unfeasible.
Meanwhile, the Plinio Seniore student proved these symbols work in real settings. Their high mark jars with Giuseppe Valditara’s call for uniformity, baring a tangible split. This divide keeps Italy banning gender-neutral language in focus.
Italy’s ban on gender-neutral language has opened Pandora’s box, cleaving opinion across age groups.
A student’s exam triumph contrasts with Giuseppe Valditara’s stern rules, upheld by the Accademia della Crusca.
Giorgia Meloni’s government pushes on, grounding policy in legacy, as her title pick shows.
Keep up with Daily Euro Times for more updates!
Read also:
Meloni Vows to Fight Against Femicide
Two Sides of the Same Coin: Gender Under the Taliban and Trump
Equality: Finnish Identity in Question
