Last Sunday, Pierbattista Pizzaballa, the Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, walked privately toward the Church of the Holy Sepulchre with a small party of four clergy to celebrate Palm Sunday Mass. Israeli police turned them back.
The Latin Patriarchate called it “the first time in centuries” church leaders had been barred from Easter’s holiest site, describing the move as “a manifestly unreasonable and grossly disproportionate measure.”
Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni expressed immediate solidarity with Cardinal Pizzaballa.
United States Ambassador Mike Huckabee – an Evangelical himself – called the ban “an unfortunate overreach already having major repercussions around the world.”
By Monday morning, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had reversed course, approving a limited prayer arrangement for the church after a wave of pressure from European and American governments.
The Pentagon’s Evangelical War Language
The Palm Sunday incident sat against a backdrop of accelerating religious framing in Washington’s prosecution of the Middle East war.
The United States and Israel launched strikes on Iran on 28 February, a conflict whose opening hours grounded over 2,000 flights in a single day and drew immediate condemnation across Europe.
Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth has since made Evangelical faith the vocabulary of the conflict, hosting monthly Christian worship services at the Pentagon featuring an exclusively Evangelical roster of preachers, with Catholic voices entirely absent from the lectern.
Last week, Hegseth read a prayer asking for “overwhelming violence of action against those who deserve no mercy” in “the mighty and powerful name of Jesus Christ,” drawing on a text originally prepared for the troops who seized Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro earlier this year.
Americans United for Separation of Church and State filed a lawsuit over the gatherings. Its chief executive Rachel Laser argued that Hegseth was abusing government resources to impose his faith on federal workers.
Pope Leo XIV Speaks From St Peter’s Square
Pope Leo XIV was addressing tens of thousands in Rome on that same Palm Sunday morning, with news of Cardinal Pizzaballa’s lockout arriving in the city as the Angelus began.
Drawing on the prophet Isaiah, Leo XIV told the crowd: “Brothers and sisters, this is our God: Jesus, King of Peace, who rejects war, whom no one can use to justify war. He does not listen to the prayers of those who wage war, but rejects them, saying: ‘Even though you make many prayers, I will not listen: your hands are full of blood.'”
Leo XIV – the first American-born pontiff – called the Middle East conflict “atrocious” and prayed for Christians across the region who had been prevented from fully living the rites of Holy Week.
The homily landed as a direct moral counterpoint to the war prayer Hegseth had delivered four days earlier, with the two men invoking the same Christian scripture and arriving at opposing conclusions about what God demands of those who hold weapons.
Europe Speaks in a Catholic Register
The European reaction to Cardinal Pizzaballa’s lockout was swift and unambiguous. French President Emmanuel Macron condemned the Israeli police decision as adding to “the alarming proliferation of violations of the status quo of Jerusalem’s Holy Sites.”
EU foreign policy chief Kaja Kallas labelled it “a violation of religious freedom and long-standing protections governing holy sites.”
Italian Foreign Minister Antonio Tajani summoned Israel’s ambassador to Rome for formal clarifications, and Germany’s Ambassador Steffen Seibert described the scene as “painful to all Christians.”
The breadth of European condemnation pointed to a Catholic political establishment prepared to deploy the language of religious rights as a distinct diplomatic register – one that sits apart from the trade frameworks and security guarantees Brussels ordinarily extends to its allies and adversaries alike.
Vance, the Catholic Broker Iran Prefers
Vice President JD Vance, a Catholic convert with a long record of scepticism toward foreign military entanglements, has emerged as the figure Iran trusts most among American negotiators.
Iranian officials have conveyed through back channels that they regard Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner as lacking credibility after the collapse of pre-war negotiations, and Vance receives a different assessment from Tehran.
“If the negotiations are going to have any outcome, JD Vance should join,” a regional source said, adding that with Witkoff and Kushner “nothing will come out of it.”
President Donald Trump formally confirmed Vance’s role in a Cabinet meeting, with a senior administration official summarising the stakes: “If the Iranians can’t strike a deal with Vance, they don’t get a deal. He’s the best they’re gonna get.”
Vance’s Catholic identity places him at a remove from the Evangelical war theology dominating the Pentagon, and that distance is precisely what makes him a credible interlocutor for Tehran.
Catholics as America’s Electoral Swing Variable
Academic literature has long called Catholic Americans the “swing vote,” a community accounting for roughly a quarter of the national electorate and splitting almost evenly between parties across recent presidential elections.
In 2024, Donald Trump secured a majority of the Catholic vote, aided in large part by JD Vance as the second Catholic Vice President in American history.
A 2026 analysis by Religion Unplugged found white Catholic voting patterns growing more fluid, and Hispanic Catholics – the community’s fastest-growing segment – showing signs of partisan recalibration ahead of the midterms.
A war prosecuted in exclusively Evangelical terms, with a cardinal barred from Easter’s holiest church, is the kind of event that accelerates such recalibration faster than any conventional policy announcement.
A coordinated Catholic pressure front emanating from Brussels and Rome remains a distinct arena in which the White House, which invested considerable effort courting Catholic votes in 2024, will feel the weight.
Rome, Brussels and the War’s Moral Geography
The question facing Europe in the weeks ahead is whether the Catholic reaction to the Palm Sunday incident coalesces into a coordinated diplomatic position.
Omani Foreign Minister Badr al-Busaidi wrote that the American administration’s “greatest miscalculation” was “allowing itself to be drawn into this war in the first place.” Rome said something similar on 29 March, in Isaiah’s language rather than geopolitical prose, addressed to the conscience of those with blood on their hands.
Europe’s translation of that moral authority into sustained diplomatic pressure remains an open question – polite condemnations are plentiful, coordinated positions are rare. JD Vance, a Catholic some see as holding the war’s best hope for a diplomatic exit, may well be the hinge on which the theology and the geopolitics finally converge.
Keep up with Daily Euro Times for more updates
Read also:
Why Spain and Latin America Defy Washington’s Venezuela Policy
Scientology’s Public Relations Push: Community Service as Strategy in Europe
Selective Outrage: Whose Suffering Does Nicki Minaj Speak For?
